The drawings replace the largest rooftop unit, but the responsibility schedule treats the HVAC as existing landlord equipment.
The construction set for a retail store fit-out in a shopping mall was read against its own responsibility schedule, and the largest new equipment, the demolition, the exit ramp and the store’s cabling either have no responsible party or have two.
Mall store responsibility schedule
Architectural, structural, mechanical, electrical, plumbing, fire alarm, security and technology drawings for a mall store fit-out, with the responsibility schedule, technology matrix and specification sheets in the set, read against one another for scope gaps, owner decisions and cost risk.
What the review compared
The review read the construction set for a retail store fit-out in a shopping mall: architectural, structural, mechanical, electrical, plumbing, fire alarm, security and technology sheets, with the responsibility schedule, a technology responsibility matrix and the specification sheets. Its instructions asked for unresolved owner decisions, scope gaps, cross-discipline conflicts and cost or value-engineering risks. Code checking was not enabled.
Where the responsibility schedule and the drawings disagree
The schedule describes a lighter project than the drawings. It treats the HVAC as existing landlord equipment while the drawings replace the largest rooftop unit with new framing and a new curb, and it gives demolition, the prefabricated exit ramp and the electrified locks on an existing exit door to no one. Store cabling and racks belong to the owner’s vendor in one matrix and to the contractor in the specification. Elsewhere, tall wall fixtures point to anchorage drawn for shorter ones, one bay’s floor is not the floor the anchorage details assume, and the only rooftop unit specification describes different equipment.
What to verify next
The owner, landlord and architect should complete the responsibility schedule for every new item and every removal before bids are leveled. The structural engineer should tie each tall fixture and the metal-deck bay to an anchorage detail that fits them, and the mechanical engineer should specify the scheduled unit. Every example is a question for the design team before pricing.
12 selected examples from the review
Twelve distinct findings, summarized for professional verification.
Largest new unit has no owner
The drawings replace a rooftop unit; the responsibility schedule treats the HVAC as existing.
Why it matters: The unit, curb and roof work may be missed or carried twice.
What to check: Assign who furnishes and installs it.
Architectural · Mechanical · Electrical · StructuralTall wall bays tagged to short anchorage
Tall custom wall bays point to an anchorage detail drawn for much shorter fixtures.
Why it matters: Their attachment and backing may be built wrong.
What to check: Tag them to the detail for their height.
Architectural · StructuralAnchorage drawn for the wrong floor
Wall and fixture anchorage assumes plank floors; one bay is concrete on metal deck.
Why it matters: Anchors in that bay have no detail.
What to check: Add metal-deck details for that bay.
StructuralDemolition assigned to no one
The responsibility schedule gives demolition no party; plans and notes require extensive removals.
Why it matters: Bidders can read demolition as outside the contract.
What to check: Name the party on the schedule.
ArchitecturalRacks and cabling owned twice
The matrix gives racks and cabling to the owner’s vendor; specification and plans to the contractor.
Why it matters: They may be priced twice or not at all.
What to check: Choose one party and align the sources.
Technology · SecurityExit ramp by others, with no other
The prefabricated exit ramp is “by others” and deferred, but no party furnishes or permits it.
Why it matters: The ramp may be left out of every price.
What to check: Add it to the schedule with a party.
Architectural · StructuralFire alarm panel new on one sheet
One keynote calls for a new fire alarm panel; the riser and specification keep the existing.
Why it matters: The fire alarm price may change substantially.
What to check: Decide new or existing and align the sheets.
Fire Protection · ElectricalSlab leveling in base bid and alternate
Slab patching and leveling are base work in three notes and an add alternate in another.
Why it matters: Base and alternate prices cannot be compared.
What to check: Define the alternate and align the notes.
ArchitecturalUnit specification for other equipment
The only rooftop unit specification covers small electric-heat units, not the large cooling-only unit.
Why it matters: Its submittal has nothing to match.
What to check: Add a section for the scheduled unit.
MechanicalDisplay platforms sent to missing details
Storefront platform details refer to structural drawings that do not show the platforms.
Why it matters: Their framing and attachment cannot be priced.
What to check: Detail the platform framing.
Architectural · StructuralPlumbing notes cite another city’s code
The plumbing notes cite another city’s plumbing and fuel gas codes, not the listed code.
Why it matters: The plumber may price the wrong rules.
What to check: Replace them with notes for the adopted code.
PlumbingExisting exit door gets electrified locks
The security plan electrifies an existing stair exit pair whose hardware is scheduled as existing.
Why it matters: No bid carries the locks or power transfer.
What to check: Add a hardware group or drop the devices.
Security · ArchitecturalReview scope and priorities
The review organized the questions by severity, discipline, and source context so the responsible designers could investigate them.
Architectural, Structural, Mechanical, Electrical, Security, and Plumbing
Check the findings with the responsible discipline designers.
High, Medium, and Low priorities
Selected examples retain their assigned priority.
Coordination and completeness within the set
This review checked the documents against one another. No code check was enabled.
Findings connected to their source context
Groundbook links each finding to the sheets it came from so the responsible designer can confirm or dismiss it.
Potential impacts describe the issue type. They are not verified outcomes from this project.
Follow the information across the complete set
Groundbook reads the documents you upload and reports where they disagree, where a reference does not resolve, and where a required value is absent.
See how a full set is reviewed or how interfaces are coordinated.
- 1Map the complete set
Identify sheets, disciplines, details, schedules, and notes.
- 2Connect repeated information
Follow tags, references, and requirements wherever they reappear.
- 3Check coordination and completeness
Compare the documents and identify missing or conflicting information.
- 4Return findings for verification
Organize potential issues by severity, discipline, and supporting context.
Questions for professional verification
The output supports the responsible designers as they review the source documents and decide what needs to change.
What this result means
- Groundbook surfaced potential issues for professional review.
- Severity helps prioritize which questions to investigate.
- The findings describe coordination and completeness questions in the uploaded set.
- Each finding includes source context for verification.
What it does not mean
- Every potential finding is a confirmed error or violation.
- The project was unsafe, unbuildable, or ultimately noncompliant.
- Groundbook replaced the responsible professionals or authority.
- A correction was made, or any cost or delay was avoided.
About this review
Is this a real review?
Based on a Groundbook review completed in November 2026. Findings are summarized.
Are these findings confirmed defects?
No. Each one is a potential issue for the responsible designer to verify against the source documents. Groundbook reports what the documents say and where they disagree. It does not make design decisions, certify compliance, or replace the authority having jurisdiction.
How long did the review take?
Turnaround runs from 20 minutes to 24 hours depending on project size.
Was a code check included?
No code check was enabled for this review. It covered coordination and completeness within the set. Code checking is available: Groundbook reads the building codes that governments publish online and uses licensed codes only where a license allows it. You can upload a copy you’re licensed to use.
Can I see a full report?
Yes. The sample plan review report shows all 79 findings from one review of a drawing set and its specifications, with the cited excerpts.
Continue from the case study
Explore the source-linked examples in the sample plan review report, or browse every published case study.
Give the next drawing set a connected first pass
Upload the project, choose the checks that matter, and receive structured potential findings with source context.