Start with the two drawing notes of the issued Section 32 17 23.16: the striping plans must show the location, width, paint type, colour, and raised pavement markers of every marking, say whether each is reflective, and carry a table or notes giving the paint type, colour, and bead type for each marking type. Then confirm that existing markings to be removed are identified, that each material can go over what is already on the pavement, and that the colours, bead types, and acceptance tables in the section cover every marking the plans show.
Assemble the review package
Gather the striping and signing plans, the marking legend or schedule, the paving plans with new and existing asphalt and concrete areas, the demolition plan showing markings to be removed, the parking layout with accessible, EV, and reserved spaces, crosswalk, stop bar, and legend details, the traffic control or phasing plan, any unit price schedule, and the issued Section 32 17 23.16 with Sections 32 13 13.06, 32 16 19, 34 60 13, 10 14 00.10, and 01 33 00, plus the installation’s marking criteria and the MUTCD edition the project follows. Follow one parking aisle and one road segment from removal to final reflectivity reading before assuming the others match.
WBDG publishes UFGS 32 17 23.16: Road and Parking Lot Pavement Markings as a public guide-specification reference (accessed November 18, 2026). Use your project’s issued specification and amendments for the actual comparison; the guide specification does not automatically govern your project. The checklist below is an original suggested review workflow, not a reproduction of the UFGS requirements.
Eight checks to run against the issued set
Use one record per location or system. The CSV contains the same eight prompts plus fields for source revisions, observed evidence, the review owner, the decision, and closure references.
| Check | Sources to compare | Question to resolve |
|---|---|---|
| What the drawings must show | Opening drawing note (existing materials to be removed or prepared; location, width, paint type, colour, and raised pavement markers; reflective or non-reflective) + Road and Parking Lot Materials note (designer prepares drawings and a table or notes giving paint type, colour, and bead type for each marking type; “NA” for non-reflective) + Reflective Media and Waterborne Paint (paint and bead types as shown on the drawings) + striping plans and legend | Does every line, stall, arrow, legend, and crosswalk on the striping plans trace to a legend row with paint type, colour, width, and bead type, are non-reflective markings marked “NA”, and does the legend use only the paint and bead types the specifier kept? |
| Existing markings and removal | Opening note (be specific about existing materials to be removed) + Quality Control Plan (removal protocol) + Surface Preparation and Paint Removal equipment (water blasting, shot blasting, grinding, chemical; new concrete curing compound bracket) + Surface Preparation and Paint Removal Test Section + material notes (thermoplastic, methacrylate, and epoxy not over other materials; tape needs all existing markings removed) + demolition and striping plans | Do the demolition or striping plans say which existing markings are removed and which are overlaid, is the new material compatible with what stays on the pavement, and where new concrete is marked, is curing compound removal kept in the section? |
| Material choice by pavement and traffic | Waterborne Paint and note (FS TT-P-1952 types for Air Force and Army; MPI 97 for Navy) + Thermoplastic note and Primer (no primer on new asphalt; primer on existing asphalt and concrete; primer brackets by pavement type) + Methacrylate, Epoxy, HBAC, and Preformed Tape notes (cold weather, durability, snowplows, temporary use) + Polyurea or Urethane placeholder + paving plans | Does each marking type in the legend have a material suited to the pavement it sits on and the traffic and snow removal it sees, does the paving plan identify new asphalt, existing asphalt, and concrete so the right primer applies, and if polyurea or urethane is shown, has the specifier filled the empty paragraph with the state or local specification the note requires? |
| Colours and accessible, EV, and reserved spaces | Marking Colors and Table I (SAE AMS-STD-595A numbers for white, yellow, black, green, red) + epoxy Composition (tints to “Federal Standard No. 595”, not in References) + Reflectivity (asks for red readings; Table VI lists white and yellow only) + parking layout, accessible stall details, EV and fire lane markings | Does every colour the plans use appear in Table I, so that blue accessible stall symbols or other colours are added or specified elsewhere, does the epoxy colour reference agree with the SAE standard, and is there an acceptance value for every reflective colour shown, including red? |
| Glass beads and wet film thickness | Reflective Media note and brackets (FS TT-B-1325 types for Air Force and Army, AASHTO M 247 for Navy; brackets offer Type III although the note says Type III is not used on roads and parking lots) + Type IV wet film ranges in the Reflective Media and HBAC notes against the Waterborne Paint note and Table III + Table III (paint type by bead type) + marking legend bead column | Does the legend pair each bead type with a paint type Table III allows, has the specifier removed the Type III bead bracket, and has one wet film range been settled for Type IV beads so the test section and acceptance readings use the same target? |
| Raised pavement markers | Raised Pavement Markers and note (button or prismatic, metallic or nonmetallic; plowable or nonplowable bracket by ASTM D4383 or D4280; broken centerline spacing “indicated” or filled in) + Raised Pavement Markers application (spacing indicated on the drawings; epoxy adhesive; water blast first) + striping plans and details | Do the striping plans show raised markers with their colour and spacing on every line that gets them, does the plowable or nonplowable choice match whether the roads are plowed, and is the spacing either drawn or filled into the bracket rather than left to both? |
| Test sections, tolerance, and acceptance | Test Sections (each line width, colour, and wet film thickness) + Wet Film Thickness and Reflective Value Test Sections (cite “Table V”; the reflectivity table is labelled Table VI) + Dimensional Tolerance and Table IV (a band of dimensions between the first and second rows has no tolerance) + Reporting, Wet Film Thickness, and Reflectivity (ASTM D4414 and E1710) + Payment (remove and replace markings without beads or below reflectivity) | Does the issued section point the test sections and reflectivity readings to the table that exists, does Table IV give a tolerance for every stall, arrow, and legend dimension the details show, and will the contractor’s reporting cover each marking element the legend lists? |
| Personnel, traffic control, payment, and material tests | Qualifications For Roads and Parking Marking Personnel (asks for airfield experience and airfield marking projects) + Traffic Control (MUTCD signs; detour plans) + Delivery, Storage, and Handling (storage on or off the installation) + Unit Prices (measurement units; Payment brackets marking removal with no removal unit) + methacrylate Abrasion Resistance (metric and inch-pound ranges disagree) + Daylight Directional Reflectance (E2302 for methacrylate, E1710 for epoxy) + HBAC Table II and note 2 (different metric values for one thickness) + Portland cement concrete primer (wet film thickness and spread rate do not agree) + phasing plan | Has the specifier rewritten the personnel experience for road and parking work, does a phasing or traffic control plan show how lanes and lots stay open, does the bid schedule pay for marking removal under a unit the measurement paragraph defines, and have the test methods, units, and primer rates been reconciled before submittals are reviewed? |
Worked example: re-striping a parking lot and marking a new access road
Illustrative example: an installation project mills and overlays part of an existing asphalt parking lot, re-stripes the rest, adds four EV charging spaces and two van-accessible stalls, and builds a new concrete access road with a crosswalk. The issued Section 32 17 23.16 keeps waterborne paint, thermoplastic for crosswalks and stop bars, raised markers, and the Type I and Type III bead brackets. The striping legend lists colours but no bead type, shows blue accessible symbols and green EV stalls, calls for thermoplastic over the existing waterborne crosswalk on the unmilled area without a removal note, and shows raised markers on the road centerline with no spacing.
Ask the civil engineer to add a bead type or “NA” to every legend row, mark the existing crosswalk for removal before thermoplastic, show raised marker spacing, and identify the concrete road so the concrete primer applies. Ask the specifier to add the blue colour the accessible symbols need, delete the Type III bead bracket, point the reflectivity paragraphs to the table that exists, and reconcile the concrete primer thickness and spread rate.
Avoid a false conflict
Section 32 17 23.16 covers marking materials, reflective media, raised markers, removal of existing markings, and their testing on roads and parking lots. Airfield and heliport markings follow Section 32 17 23.19 and UFC 3-260-04, concrete and asphalt pavement follow their own paving sections, such as 32 13 13.06, curbs and sidewalks follow Section 32 16 19, EV charging spaces follow Section 34 60 13, permanent signs follow Section 10 14 00.10, and the stall layout, accessible spaces, and crosswalk geometry come from the drawings and the accessibility standard and MUTCD edition the project follows, so check those before calling a requirement missing. Some of the section’s own wording needs resolving: road and parking crews must show airfield experience, two marking tables are cited by the wrong number, red markings have no reflectivity value, Table IV skips a band of dimensions, Type III beads are offered against the note, Type IV wet film ranges differ, test methods and units disagree between methacrylate and epoxy, the HBAC table and note give different metric values, the concrete primer rate and thickness disagree, and removal is paid without a unit. Ask the specifier which wording the project intends before treating a difference as a design conflict.
When requirements disagree, follow the project’s document-control and clarification process. Do not assume that drawings always override specifications, or the reverse. Identify the exact sources and request an authorized decision.
Close the issue across the affected documents
Record the location or tag, drawing and specification references, issue dates, observed difference, and the decision needed. Assign an owner and keep the item open until the response identifies the governing requirement. Check the revised drawings and specification references together; a response email alone may leave the issued package inconsistent.
For the overall process, use the guide to drawing and specification conflicts. Mark an inapplicable checklist row with a reason, and distinguish a verified correction from a question that still needs design information.
Where Groundbook fits
Groundbook’s drawing and specification review helps investigate potential disagreements in the documents you supply. Include the relevant specification sections and drawing references, then verify the cited evidence with the responsible reviewers before acting on a finding.