Start with the mechanical piping plans and the issued Section 23 23 00: confirm that every field-piped refrigerant circuit is drawn from its compressor or condensing unit to each evaporator, that the designer has detailed any below-grade run and how oil returns, and that the scheduled refrigerant is one the section was written for. Then check that the piping legend, valve and accessory arrangement, supports, and penetrations match the kept paragraphs, and that the drawings state the design pressure the pneumatic test needs.
Assemble the review package
Gather the mechanical floor and roof plans with refrigerant line routing, the refrigerant piping schematic or riser, the equipment schedules for condensing units, air handlers, VRF, computer room, or refrigeration equipment with their refrigerant designations, the piping legend and material schedule, the support, seismic bracing, and anchor details, the architectural penetration, roof flashing, and rated-wall details, any cold room or walk-in cooler drawings, the insulation schedule, and the issued Section 23 23 00 with Sections 23 07 00, 23 05 48.19, 13 48 73, 23 05 93, 07 84 00, 09 90 00, and the equipment sections that send piping here. Follow one circuit from the compressor through the condenser, liquid line, expansion device, evaporator, and suction line before assuming the others match.
WBDG publishes UFGS 23 23 00: Refrigerant Piping as a public guide-specification reference (accessed November 17, 2026). Use your project’s issued specification and amendments for the actual comparison; the guide specification does not automatically govern your project. The checklist below is an original suggested review workflow, not a reproduction of the UFGS requirements.
Eight checks to run against the issued set
Use one record per location or system. The CSV contains the same eight prompts plus fields for source revisions, observed evidence, the review owner, the decision, and closure references.
| Check | Sources to compare | Question to resolve |
|---|---|---|
| What the drawings must show | Contract Drawings (small scale; not every offset, fitting, and accessory shown) + Refrigerant Piping System (SD-02 drawings: piping layouts identifying valves and fittings; plans and elevations with maintenance clearances) + Installation note (avoid belowground piping; never direct buried; designer details the trench and the piping that keeps oil circulating at full and part load; avoid oil traps) + Functional Requirements (slope for oil drainage; fit the space allotted) + mechanical plans, schematic, and connection details | Do the plans show every field-piped circuit from compressor or condensing unit to each evaporator with routing, risers, and equipment connections, is any below-grade run drawn in an accessible trench with its detail, does the designer, rather than the shop drawings, show how oil returns at part load, and will the contractor’s piping layout be reviewed against those plans? |
| Refrigerant group and safety interfaces | Opening note (inside buildings or from adjacent equipment) + Refrigerant Piping System note (written for Group A1 refrigerants; other groups such as B1 or ammonia need research in ASHRAE 15 & 34 and ASME B31.5 and editing) + Refrigerant Piping Tests note (tests do not apply to factory-charged packaged unitary equipment) + no refrigerant detector, machinery room, or relief discharge paragraph in the section + equipment schedules and the VRF, unitary, chiller, and computer room sections | Does every scheduled system use a refrigerant in the group the section was written for, and if not, has the specifier rewritten materials, joints, and tests, is it clear which systems are field-piped and so fall under the Part 3 tests, and do the equipment sections and drawings, not this section, cover refrigerant detection, machinery room ventilation, and relief discharge where ASHRAE 15 & 34 requires them? |
| Piping code, welding, and steel pipe | Refrigerant Piping System (ASHRAE 15 & 34 and ASME B31.5) + Installation and Welded Connections (ASME B31.1 Power Piping) + Welded Fittings (valves and pipe connections to ASME B31.9) + Qualifications and note (ASME BPVC Section IX; welders accepted as ASME B31.1 permits; Navy bracket citing 40 17 26.00 20 as “Welding Process Piping”, titled Welding Pressure Piping on WBDG) + Steel Pipe note (designer decides whether 45-degree elbows are allowed; no paragraph records it) + Steel Pipe and Steel Tubing paragraphs | Has the specifier settled which piping code governs installation, welding, and inspection, since the section cites three, corrected the Navy welding section title, and written into the text whether 45-degree elbows are allowed, as the steel pipe note asks, and is steel pipe kept only where the drawings actually show steel refrigerant lines? |
| Tube, joints, and brazing | Copper Tubing (ACR marking; soft annealed only for bending and smaller sizes; brazed joints with flared joints allowed on small lines; no cast sweat fittings for brazed joints) + Brazing Filler Metal and Brazing Flux (silver alloy with flux; phosphorus-copper alloys allowed copper-to-copper; aluminum filler for aluminum components) + Brazed Connections (nitrogen purge; no flux on copper-to-copper; steel tubing joints painted to match a “baked-on coating” Steel Tubing never specifies) + Press Fittings (not acceptable) + piping legend or material schedule | Does the piping legend name the same tube, joint, and fitting types as the kept paragraphs, is any press fitting shown on a detail or allowed in an equipment manufacturer’s instructions removed, does the brazing procedure use a flux-free filler for copper-to-copper joints, and has the specifier defined the steel tubing coating or deleted the painting sentence? |
| Valves, accessories, and oil management | Valves (refrigerant-rated; end connections by size bracket; no threaded ends except pilot and gauge lines) + stop, check, solenoid, expansion, electronic expansion, relief, regulator, and access valves + Filter Driers, Sight Glass, Strainers, Pressure Gauges, Temperature Gauges (the remote-gauge mounting band lacks “more than” and overlaps the middle band) + installation of stop valves, strainers, a dryer on each circuit, sight glass downstream, an oil separator on each compressor (unbracketed), and an accumulator on each compressor (note limits it to extended split-system lines) + piping schematic | Does the schematic show the stop valves, filter-drier, sight glass, strainer, solenoid, and expansion device the installation paragraphs require on each circuit, does the specifier intend an oil separator and accumulator on every compressor, including factory-packaged units, or should both paragraphs be limited to where the schedule shows them, and has the temperature gauge mounting wording been corrected? |
| Supports, seismic bracing, and penetrations | Pipe Hangers, Inserts, and Supports (MSS SP-58 types and exclusions) + horizontal and vertical supports, guides, slides, multiple runs, alignment guides, and anchors (anchor drawings submitted) + Seismic Requirements and note (details shown if a Government designer is engineer of record; UFC 3-301-01; Sections 13 48 73 and 23 05 48.19) + Building Surface Penetrations (sleeves in structural members allowed “where indicated or approved”, then banned outright) + Refrigerated Space, Waterproof, and Fire-Rated Penetrations (Section 07 84 00) + structural and architectural details | Do the drawings show support, anchor, and seismic bracing details or point to Section 23 05 48.19, are any sleeves through structural members indicated where the first sentence allows them though the last sentence bans them, are roof and rated-wall penetrations detailed, and do cold room penetrations show the vapor-sealed sleeve the refrigerated space paragraph describes? |
| Insulation, painting, and identification | Factory Applied Insulation (ASHRAE 90.1; brackets for cooler-to-compressor suction lines and absorption chiller lines; ASTM E84 indexes) + Field Applied Insulation (Section 23 07 00) + Factory Coating and note (salt spray bracket for outdoor items) + Field Painting and Color Coding (Section 09 90 00 cited as “Paints and Coatings”; note citing AFM 88-15, not in References) + Color Coding Scheme note (“10” and “20” suffixes the bracketed 22 00 00 and 22 00 70 do not carry) + Valve Identification and Identification Tags + insulation schedule | Does the insulation schedule cover suction and other cold lines outside factory equipment, including outdoor runs, with the jacket Section 23 07 00 calls for, are the chiller brackets deleted where no chiller is in the project, is the outdoor coating bracket chosen for the site, and has the specifier fixed the painting citation and the color coding notes? |
| Pressure, evacuation, charging, and leak tests | Refrigerant Piping Tests note (field-fabricated piping only; leak test at the design pressure for the highest ambient per ASHRAE 15 & 34) + Preliminary Procedures (isolate factory-charged equipment; remove relief valves and rupture discs) + Pneumatic Test (dry nitrogen; two stages; leak test at “the design pressure, or a pressure specified in the engineering design”) + Evacuation Test (“Do not evacuate no more than one system at one time by one vacuum pump”) + System Charging and Startup + Refrigerant Leakage and Contractor’s Responsibility (Clean Air Act Section 608 leak rates stated as allowable) + Section 23 05 93 coordination | Do the schedules or general notes state the design pressure for each field-piped circuit so the test pressure can be set, has the specifier fixed the double negative in the evacuation paragraph, does the charge come from the equipment manufacturer’s data for the installed line lengths, and have the leak rate sentences been checked against the current federal refrigerant management rules? |
Worked example: split systems and a walk-in cooler in an administration building
Illustrative example: a two-story administration building is served by three split-system air handling units with remote condensing units on a pad beside the building, and a walk-in cooler in the break room kitchen. The issued Section 23 23 00 keeps the steel pipe paragraphs, the absorption chiller insulation bracket, the oil separator and accumulator paragraphs for every compressor, and the evacuation sentence with its double negative. The mechanical plans route the suction and liquid lines under the slab-on-grade to an interior chase with no trench detail, the piping legend allows press fittings, the cooler wall penetration has no sleeve detail, and no schedule or note gives the design pressure for any circuit.
Ask the mechanical engineer to reroute the lines overhead or detail an accessible trench with the oil-return arrangement, to remove press fittings from the legend, to add a vapor-sealed sleeve detail at the cooler wall, and to state the design pressure for each circuit. Ask the specifier to delete the steel pipe and chiller paragraphs, to limit the oil separator and accumulator paragraphs to the equipment that needs them, to settle which piping code governs installation, and to correct the evacuation sentence before the test procedure is submitted.
Avoid a false conflict
Section 23 23 00 covers field refrigerant piping, its accessories, and its tests. The equipment follows its own section, such as 23 81 00, 23 81 29, or 23 81 23, insulation follows Section 23 07 00, seismic bracing follows Sections 23 05 48.19 and 13 48 73, firestopping follows Section 07 84 00, balancing follows Section 23 05 93, and ASHRAE 15 & 34, ASME B31.5, the adopted mechanical code, and UFC 3-410-01 govern refrigerant safety, so check those before calling a requirement missing. Some of the section’s own wording needs resolving: three piping codes are cited, the 45-degree elbow decision has no paragraph, steel tubing joints are painted to match an unspecified coating, two temperature gauge mounting bands overlap, sleeves in structural members are both allowed and banned, the evacuation paragraph has a double negative, and the Navy welding, painting, and color coding citations do not match current WBDG titles or References. Ask the specifier which wording the project intends before treating a difference as a design conflict.
When requirements disagree, follow the project’s document-control and clarification process. Do not assume that drawings always override specifications, or the reverse. Identify the exact sources and request an authorized decision.
Close the issue across the affected documents
Record the location or tag, drawing and specification references, issue dates, observed difference, and the decision needed. Assign an owner and keep the item open until the response identifies the governing requirement. Check the revised drawings and specification references together; a response email alone may leave the issued package inconsistent.
For the overall process, use the guide to drawing and specification conflicts. Mark an inapplicable checklist row with a reason, and distinguish a verified correction from a question that still needs design information.
Where Groundbook fits
Groundbook’s drawing and specification review helps investigate potential disagreements in the documents you supply. Include the relevant specification sections and drawing references, then verify the cited evidence with the responsible reviewers before acting on a finding.