Start with the mechanical schedules and the issued Section 23 81 29: confirm that the drawings show the VRF system type the Summary keeps, the outdoor and indoor unit capacities, design ambient or water temperatures, the zones and their controls, branch selector locations, leak detector and relief locations where they are needed, and how ventilation and dehumidification are met, since the section says VRF systems have limited capability for both. Then check that the contractor design drawings, refrigerant calculations, controls protocol, and cross-referenced sections match, and that the section’s outdated section titles and conflicting fan, heater, and pressure vessel wording are resolved.
Assemble the review package
Gather the mechanical equipment schedules for outdoor units, indoor fan coil units, branch selector units, and any supplemental heaters, the floor plans and reflected ceiling plans with indoor unit locations, the roof or site plan with outdoor units, pads, and screens, the refrigerant piping riser or schematic if the designer drew one, the ventilation and dedicated outdoor air design, the controls points schedule and sequences of operation, the electrical plans and panel schedules for outdoor unit feeds and disconnects, the room sizes behind any refrigerant concentration calculation, and the issued Section 23 81 29 with Sections 23 09 00, 23 09 13, the BACnet or LonWorks section, 25 05 11, 23 23 00, 23 07 00, 23 05 48.19, 22 00 00, and the testing and balancing or commissioning section. Follow one refrigerant system from its outdoor unit through its branch selectors to its smallest occupied room before assuming the others match.
WBDG publishes UFGS 23 81 29: Variable Refrigerant Flow HVAC Systems as a public guide-specification reference (accessed November 15, 2026). Use your project’s issued specification and amendments for the actual comparison; the guide specification does not automatically govern your project. The checklist below is an original suggested review workflow, not a reproduction of the UFGS requirements.
Eight checks to run against the issued set
Use one record per location or system. The CSV contains the same eight prompts plus fields for source revisions, observed evidence, the review owner, the decision, and closure references.
| Check | Sources to compare | Question to resolve |
|---|---|---|
| What the drawings must show | Summary (air source or water source; cooling only, heat pump, simultaneous heating and cooling, or heat recovery; zone control type; branch selector boxes for simultaneous systems) and note (limited dehumidification and outdoor air; UFC 3-410-01) + Outdoor Compressor Unit (capacity to meet or exceed the scheduled value; outdoor to connected indoor capacity ratio by the manufacturer) + Air-Cooled (design ambient blanks) and note (outside air temperatures from the approved load calculations) + Water-Cooled (water temperature ranges identified in the contract drawings) + mechanical schedules | Do the schedules state the system type the issued Summary keeps, list each outdoor unit with its capacity and the indoor units it serves, carry the design ambient or condenser water temperatures that fill the section’s blanks, and do the drawings show how ventilation air and dehumidification are delivered, by a dedicated outdoor air system or otherwise, since the section warns VRF units cannot be assumed to do either? |
| Contractor design drawings and refrigerant calculations | Quality Assurance (single supplier responsible for a fully functional system) + VRF System Contractor Design Drawings (to scale; approved by the manufacturer’s representative; layouts, clearances, foundations, supports conforming to “Section 23 05 48.19 SEISMIC BRACING FOR HVAC”, now titled Seismic Bracing for Mechanical Systems; refrigerant type and charge; piping plans under Section 23 23 00; schedules; refrigerant mass and expansion calculations; sequence of operations; ASHRAE 15 and 34 calculations) and note (modify Section 23 23 00 so piping plans travel with this submittal) + Manufacturer’s Engineering Data | Has the specifier edited Section 23 23 00 so that the VRF piping plans are submitted with the contractor design drawings, as the note asks, corrected the seismic bracing cross-reference to the current section title, and kept the refrigerant mass and ASHRAE 15 and 34 calculations, and do the design drawings leave the contractor enough room, ceiling space, and shaft space to route the manufacturer’s piping without moving the units the schedules fix? |
| Refrigerant safety, leak detection, relief, and signs | Refrigerant (number designations and safety classifications to ASHRAE 15 and 34; ozone depletion exception for R-123, a chiller refrigerant; SDS sheets) + Refrigerant Leak Detector (installed where indicated) and note (location indicated on the drawings; alarm, ventilation, and signage at the room entrance; electrical design for the alarm on the drawings; open-flame devices; written around a mechanical room) + Refrigerant Relief Valve/Rupture Disc Assembly and note (designer indicates each assembly and the routing and size of relief piping) + Refrigerant Signs + room plans | Does the refrigerant concentration calculation the section requires use the smallest room each system serves, and if it shows a detector is needed, do the floor plans, electrical plans, and controls drawings show the detector, its alarms, and the ventilation it starts, for occupied rooms as well as any mechanical room, and does the mechanical set show the relief assemblies and discharge piping the note asks for or state that the factory units need none? |
| Controls, protocol, and cybersecurity | Tailoring note (BACnet Only and LonWorks Only both printed as selected; only one may remain) + controls note (UFC 3-410-02 sets the open protocol exception process) + Summary (Section 23 09 00 governs; exception “by Section 23 09 00”; Section 25 05 11 cybersecurity) + Controls + Zone Control (space sensor module per Section 23 09 13 for each fan coil unless indicated; override bracket) + Controls installation (Points Schedule; Local Display panel as indicated on the points schedule) + Project Sequencing + O&M and Training notes (modify Section 23 09 00) | Has one protocol been chosen and matched in Sections 23 09 00 and the BACnet or LonWorks section, and if the selected VRF system cannot meet the open protocol requirement, is there a documented exception under UFC 3-410-02 rather than a sentence that leaves it to Section 23 09 00, do the controls drawings include a points schedule that lists the VRF points and the local display panel, and do the floor plans show a sensor at each zone or say which fan coils share one? |
| Indoor units, fans, heaters, filters, and dampers | Indoor Fan Coil Units (variable speed ECM or multi-speed fan bracket; filters; condensate pump safety and overflow protection) + Concealed-In-Ceiling, Recessed Ceiling, and Wall Surface-Mounted Units (housing color blanks) + Fans (direct-drive fan motors of the multiple-speed variety; belt drives, sheaves, centrifugal scroll and propeller fans) + Supplemental Electric Heating Coil (electric duct heater cited to UL 1995, titled Heating and Cooling Equipment) + Summary two-stage heating bracket + Internal Dampers (integral to the unitary unit; economizer) and Mixing Boxes + reflected ceiling plans | Which fan requirement governs the fan coils, the ECM option in Indoor Fan Coil Units or the multiple-speed motors and belt-drive text in Fans, and has the specifier cut the fan, damper, and mixing box text that VRF fan coils do not use, are supplemental heaters scheduled and cited to a duct heater standard, and do the reflected ceiling plans show each cassette and ducted unit with access and the housing color chosen? |
| Outdoor units, branch selectors, and locations | Outdoor Compressor Unit (sound level blank to ANSI/AHRI 270; automatic restart; each unit with its own dedicated power feed, disconnect, and main circuit breaker) + Casing + Branch Selector Unit (port control for each indoor unit unless otherwise indicated) + Branch Selector installation (inside the facility; height and clearance limits; removable without modification) + Equipment General (isolate outdoor units from the structure; pads or pedestals under Section 03 30 00; units not blowing toward other intakes) + Flashing and Pitch Pockets + coil and equipment coatings + roof, site, and electrical plans | Do the electrical plans and panel schedules give every outdoor unit its own feed and disconnect, do the roof or site plans space and orient outdoor units so none discharges toward another’s intake, are sound-sensitive neighbors considered against the sound blank, do the plans place each branch selector inside the building within the height and clearance limits the section sets, and does the coil coating suit the site’s corrosion exposure? |
| Piping, condensate, pressure vessels, and insulation | Refrigerant Piping (Section 23 23 00) + Isolation Valves and note (only if the end user requires them) + Pressure Vessels (ASME BPVC SEC VIII D1) + Suction Accumulator (ASME BPVC SEC VIII, a separate, older References entry) + Oil Separator and Oil Reservoir (each refrigerant circuit; oil level regulators) + Condensate Removal (gravity where possible, otherwise a pump) + Auxiliary Drain Pans (under units above ceilings or over equipment) + Field Applied Insulation and refrigerant piping (Section 23 07 00) + Access Panels + plumbing plans | Has the specifier removed the field-built receiver, accumulator, separator, and reservoir text where the outdoor units are factory packaged, and pointed the pressure vessel paragraphs at one edition of Section VIII, do the plumbing plans show where each fan coil’s condensate goes and which units need pumps and auxiliary pans, are access panels shown at concealed fan coils, valves, and joints, and does the insulation section cover refrigerant lines outside the units? |
| Testing, charging, commissioning, and closeout | Refrigerant Piping Tests (Section 23 23 00; witnessed; calibrated detector) + Refrigerant Charging (weight from the shop drawing calculations; report) + System Performance Tests (heating and cooling seasons; simultaneous mode; two bound reports with overlapping content; coordinate with Section 01 91 00.15 or “23 05 93 TESTING, ADJUSTING, AND BALANCING OF HVAC SYSTEMS”, now titled Testing, Adjusting, and Balancing for HVAC) + Warranty and note (maximum common warranty among three manufacturers) + Closeout, O&M, Posted Instructions, and Training | Has the specifier chosen commissioning or testing and balancing for the field tests and used the current section title, does the project schedule allow performance testing in both heating and cooling seasons, has the warranty bracket been filled from the research the note describes, and will the charging report be checked against the refrigerant mass in the approved calculations? |
Worked example: a heat recovery VRF system in a barracks with a small office and no leak detection shown
Illustrative example: a barracks renovation uses two air-source heat recovery VRF systems with ducted fan coils in the corridors and wall-mounted units in the rooms, and a dedicated outdoor air unit for ventilation. The issued Section 23 81 29 keeps both protocol options, keeps the Fans, Internal Dampers, Oil Reservoir, and Suction Accumulator paragraphs as printed, and leaves the design ambient blanks empty. The schedules list outdoor unit capacities but no design temperatures, the floor plans show no branch selector units, the electrical plans feed both outdoor units from one disconnect, one system serves a small office whose volume is not checked against the refrigerant charge, and the controls drawings have no points schedule.
Ask the mechanical engineer to add the design temperatures to the schedules, to locate the branch selectors, to run the ASHRAE 15 and 34 check for the small office and show any detector, alarm, and ventilation it requires, and to add the VRF points to a points schedule. Ask the electrical engineer to give each outdoor unit its own feed and disconnect. Ask the specifier to choose one protocol, to remove the fan, damper, and pressure vessel text the factory units do not use, to correct the seismic bracing and testing section titles, and to cite a duct heater standard if supplemental heat is kept.
Avoid a false conflict
Section 23 81 29 covers the VRF system and its equipment. Refrigerant piping follows Section 23 23 00, controls follow Section 23 09 00 and the BACnet or LonWorks section and the HVAC controls guides, packaged and split units outside a VRF system follow Section 23 81 00 and the unitary HVAC guide, ventilation units follow their own sections and the dedicated outdoor air guide, insulation and seismic bracing follow their own sections and guides, and ASHRAE 15 and 34, ASHRAE 90.1, the mechanical code, and UFC 3-410-01 govern design, so check those before calling a requirement missing. Some of the section’s own wording needs resolving: two cross-referenced section titles are outdated, the Fans paragraph requires multiple-speed direct-drive motors and belt drives while the fan coil paragraph offers ECM fans, the supplemental heater is cited to a heating and cooling equipment standard, and two editions of ASME Section VIII are cited for the same kind of vessel. Ask the specifier which wording the project intends before treating a difference as a design conflict.
When requirements disagree, follow the project’s document-control and clarification process. Do not assume that drawings always override specifications, or the reverse. Identify the exact sources and request an authorized decision.
Close the issue across the affected documents
Record the location or tag, drawing and specification references, issue dates, observed difference, and the decision needed. Assign an owner and keep the item open until the response identifies the governing requirement. Check the revised drawings and specification references together; a response email alone may leave the issued package inconsistent.
For the overall process, use the guide to drawing and specification conflicts. Mark an inapplicable checklist row with a reason, and distinguish a verified correction from a question that still needs design information.
Where Groundbook fits
Groundbook’s drawing and specification review helps investigate potential disagreements in the documents you supply. Include the relevant specification sections and drawing references, then verify the cited evidence with the responsible reviewers before acting on a finding.