Start with the drawing note of the issued Section 07 32 13: confirm that the roof plan gives the pitch of every tile roof and that details show the eave, rake, ridge, valley, and each intersection with a wall, chimney, or dormer. Then check that the tile profile on the drawings matches the one application paragraph kept, that the fittings the details draw are the ones the Fittings brackets choose, that the deck type on the structural drawings matches the kept underlayment and fastening paragraphs, and that the reroof plan marks which existing tile is salvaged and which is replaced.
Assemble the review package
Gather the roof plan with slopes, drainage, and snow guard locations, the eave, rake, ridge, hip, valley, wall, chimney, and penetration details, the existing roof survey or reroof demolition plan marking tile to salvage, the structural roof framing and deck type, the wind design criteria and any hail exposure from the structural or general notes, the energy compliance documents if a cool roof is required, the project climate data for freeze-thaw exposure and ice dams, and the issued Section 07 32 13 with Section 07 60 00 and the roofing criteria of UFC 3-110-03. Follow one roof plane from the ridge down to the gutter, through each fitting, strip, membrane lap, and flashing, before assuming the others match.
WBDG publishes UFGS 07 32 13: Concrete Tile Roofing Replacement or Repair as a public guide-specification reference (accessed November 16, 2026). Use your project’s issued specification and amendments for the actual comparison; the guide specification does not automatically govern your project. The checklist below is an original suggested review workflow, not a reproduction of the UFGS requirements.
Eight checks to run against the issued set
Use one record per location or system. The CSV contains the same eight prompts plus fields for source revisions, observed evidence, the review owner, the decision, and closure references.
| Check | Sources to compare | Question to resolve |
|---|---|---|
| What the drawings must show | Drawing note (pitch of substrate and tile roofing; roof edge, rake, ridge, valley, and intersections with vertical surfaces) + New Concrete Tile (“shapes as indicated”; special shapes for ridges, rakes, and hips) + Vertical Membrane Flashings (“turn up walls and dormers as indicated”) + Metal Flashing (“as shown”) + Snow Guards (“as indicated”) + Protection of Roof Surfaces (breakage “beyond what is indicated”) + roof plan and details | Does the roof plan give a pitch for every tile roof, do details cover each edge, rake, ridge, hip, valley, wall, chimney, and dormer condition the plan shows, and do the drawings also carry the items the text says are indicated: the tile shapes, the membrane turn-up height at walls, the snow guard layout, and any tile breakage allowance on a reroof? |
| Clay or concrete, and which tile profile | Opening note (covers clay and concrete roofing tiles) + title and Part 2 (concrete tile only) + New Concrete Tile (ASTM C1492 extruded, interlocking units; also cites ASTM C67/C67M, titled for brick and structural clay tile) + Protection of Elastomeric Membranes (cover with “clay tile roofing”) + Repair and Replacement (intermingle “clay tiles”) + One-Piece Barrel, Two-Piece Barrel, Flat Shingle, and Interlocking Shingle Tile Application + roof elevations and tile callouts | Is the existing or new roof concrete tile, or clay tile that this section does not specify, does the profile on the drawings (barrel, flat, or interlocking) match a product the tile paragraph actually describes, since it names only extruded interlocking units, and has the specifier deleted the application paragraphs for profiles the project does not use and corrected the clay references and the clay test method? |
| Fittings, hips, ridges, and valleys | Fittings (bracketed eave closure or under eave, end band or gable rake, ridge, closed ridge end, ridge/hip terminal, cut hip, hip roll, hip starter, cut valley or closed valley) + barrel application steps (mortar-filled hip and ridge ends and site-mitered terminals only when the fittings are not specified) + flat and interlocking shingle steps (mortar fill and site mitering required without that condition) + Mortar (cut valley openings) + ridge, hip, and valley details | Do the ridge, hip, and valley details draw the same fittings the Fittings brackets keep, and where a flat or interlocking tile roof keeps ridge/hip terminals or hip starters, has the specifier made the mortar fill and site mitering steps conditional, as the barrel paragraphs are, so the installer is not told to do both? |
| Deck, substrate panels, and wood strips | Examination (deck complies with the selected system) + Substrate Panels (fiberglass-faced gypsum roof board over structural metal deck) + Elastomeric Membrane Underlayment (over wood deck, concrete deck, or substrate panels; plywood over pine decks) + Poured Concrete Deck (embedded wood strips, felts fastened with lath, horizontal strips) + Wood Strips (redwood or preservative-treated Douglas fir; sizes per the tile manufacturer) + Nails (verify treatment compatibility with copper) + structural deck and framing | Does the deck on the structural drawings match one kept bracket, and if it is a poured concrete deck, has the specifier rewritten the paragraph that fastens felts the section never specifies, does a replacement or repair project actually include new substrate panels or new deck work, as the panel and concrete deck paragraphs assume, and do the details size the battens, stringers, and cant strips for the chosen profile and name a treatment compatible with the fasteners? |
| Underlayment, ice dams, and wall turn-ups | Underlayment Membrane (high strength elastomeric self-adhering membrane on surfaces scheduled for tile) + Elastomeric Membrane Underlayment (primer on concrete; ice dam protection above the highest expected ice dam level; laps; fold at roof edge under edge metal) + Valley and Ridge Application + Vertical Membrane Flashings (primer; mechanically fastened terminations; fold onto fascia under gutter metal) + Protection (exposure limit; stated twice) + eave, valley, and wall details | Do the eave details show where the membrane folds over the edge and how the edge metal and gutter cover it, have the drawings or the specifier set the ice dam line for the project’s climate, do the wall and dormer details show the membrane turn-up and its fastened termination behind counterflashing, and will the schedule keep the membrane covered within the exposure limit on a phased reroof? |
| Fasteners, flashing metals, and wind | Nails and Threaded Fasteners (solid copper or stainless steel) + Miscellaneous Fasteners (wind locks, hurricane clips, tile brackets, tile-tie, deck anchors, cleats; copper or stainless) + Tile Removal (re-fasten with copper fasteners) + Flashing (copper, lead-coated copper, or stainless steel; like metals; Section 07 60 00) + Sheet Metal Birdstop (stainless, prefinished) + Installation (local building code for wind locks and hurricane clips) + tile application steps (fasteners by slope, building height, and wind) + structural wind criteria | Has the project chosen one flashing metal and matching fasteners, since the removal paragraph asks for copper fasteners where the fastener paragraphs allow stainless steel, do the details show fasteners kept clear of sheet metal as the application steps require, and do the wind design criteria in the drawings, rather than an unnamed local code, set the fastening, clips, and adhesive the manufacturer’s tested assembly needs? |
| Reroof salvage, color, impact, fire, and cool roof | Existing Concrete Tile (salvage and reuse; match new to existing; same manufacturer if possible) + Tile Removal (verify each tile; mark for approval after Notice to Proceed) + New Concrete Tile note (integral color only in high freeze-thaw areas; impact bracket for hail-prone areas, UL 2218 or FM 4473) + ASTM E108 cited without a class + Solar Reflectance (Cool Roof Products bracket undefined; Heat Island Reduction submittal) + Colors (manufacturer’s standard samples) + reroof plan and energy documents | Does the reroof plan mark the areas of replacement and salvage the section expects, is integral color kept where the climate calls for it, is the impact bracket kept only if the site is hail-prone, does the code analysis state the roof covering fire classification the drawings rely on, and if a cool roof is required, have the specifier and energy design agreed on the criteria and the color range that meets them? |
| Extra stock, warranties, conference, and records | Extra Stock (an extra percentage of each type and color of “slate”) + Contractor’s Warranty + Manufacturer’s Warranty (NDL, including related metal flashing) + Coordination (flashing and gutters under Section 07 60 00) + Pre-roofing Conference (reviews the manufacturer’s technical representative’s substrate inspection and acceptance, which no paragraph requires) + Sealant (ASTM C1184, titled for structural silicone sealants, in lieu of plastic cement) + Roof Information Card + shop drawings | Has the specifier changed “slate” to concrete tile in Extra Stock and included the fittings in the same proportion, does the manufacturer’s warranty on flashing match who furnishes the flashing under Section 07 60 00, is a manufacturer’s substrate inspection actually required, as the conference agenda assumes, and is the sealant standard the one intended for sealing tile to tile and to metal? |
Worked example: a partial reroof of interlocking tile with a new addition on a metal deck
Illustrative example: an installation chapel with an interlocking concrete tile roof is getting a partial reroof over the nave and a new vestibule addition with a steel roof deck. The issued Section 07 32 13 keeps all four application paragraphs and the poured concrete deck paragraph, keeps the clay tile wording in the membrane protection and repair paragraphs, and asks for extra “slate”. The vestibule framing plan shows a corrugated metal deck, the roof plan gives the nave pitch but not the vestibule pitch, the ridge detail draws hip starters that the flat and interlocking steps would replace with mortar fill, and the reroof plan does not mark which existing tile is salvaged.
Ask the architect to add the vestibule pitch, a reroof plan marking tile to salvage and replace, and the wall turn-up and edge details at the addition. Ask the specifier to keep only the interlocking paragraph, to delete the poured concrete deck paragraph and keep the substrate panel paragraph for the metal deck, to replace the clay and slate wording, to make the mortar fill and mitering steps conditional on the fittings kept, and to choose one flashing metal with matching fasteners.
Avoid a false conflict
Section 07 32 13 covers concrete tile roofing with its underlayment, fasteners, birdstops, wood strips, and snow guards. Flashing and gutters follow Section 07 60 00 and the flashing and sheet metal guide, slate follows Section 07 31 26 and the slate guide, asphalt shingles follow Section 07 31 13 and the shingle guide, roof insulation follows its own section and guide, and the roofing criteria in UFC 3-110-03, the building code, and the wind and fire classifications govern performance, so check those before calling a requirement missing. Some of the section’s own wording needs resolving: the opening note says clay and concrete while the rest says concrete, two Part 3 paragraphs and a test method refer to clay tile, Extra Stock says slate, the tile paragraph names only interlocking units while four profiles get application paragraphs, the poured deck paragraph fastens felts that are not specified, the mortar paragraph mixes two kinds of mortar, the removal and fastener paragraphs name different metals, the shingle tile steps ignore the fittings brackets, and the conference reviews an inspection no paragraph requires. Ask the specifier which wording the project intends before treating a difference as a design conflict.
When requirements disagree, follow the project’s document-control and clarification process. Do not assume that drawings always override specifications, or the reverse. Identify the exact sources and request an authorized decision.
Close the issue across the affected documents
Record the location or tag, drawing and specification references, issue dates, observed difference, and the decision needed. Assign an owner and keep the item open until the response identifies the governing requirement. Check the revised drawings and specification references together; a response email alone may leave the issued package inconsistent.
For the overall process, use the guide to drawing and specification conflicts. Mark an inapplicable checklist row with a reason, and distinguish a verified correction from a question that still needs design information.
Where Groundbook fits
Groundbook’s drawing and specification review helps investigate potential disagreements in the documents you supply. Include the relevant specification sections and drawing references, then verify the cited evidence with the responsible reviewers before acting on a finding.