Start with the drawing note of the issued Section 08 34 63: confirm that the drawings give every opening its size, door thickness, swing or travel, wall size, glazing type and thickness, frame anchorage method, and any view window, speaking port, louver, view port, or food pass, and that a complete door schedule gives each opening a number, type, size, and detention hardware set. Then check that the frame anchorage on the details matches one of the section’s three descriptions for the actual wall construction, that every lock, electric strike, and position switch on the hardware sets has a matching reinforcement or housing, and that glazing, finish paint, and access panel locks have a home in another section.
Assemble the review package
Gather the floor plans with door numbers and the security perimeter, the door schedule and door type and frame elevations, the abbreviation list, the wall types for masonry, concrete, and any other partitions that receive detention frames, the head, jamb, and sill details with anchors and grout, the view window and port details, the detention hardware sets, the electrical and security drawings showing electric locks, position switches, and conduit to frames, the reflected ceiling and mechanical plans showing chases and access panels, and the issued Section 08 34 63 with Sections 08 71 63, 08 11 13, 08 31 00, 04 20 00, 08 81 00 or the project’s security glazing section, 09 90 00, and 28 10 05. Follow one cell door from the plan to its schedule row, frame detail, hardware set, and electrical connection before assuming the others match.
WBDG publishes UFGS 08 34 63: Detention Hollow Metal Frames, Doors, and Door Frames as a public guide-specification reference (accessed November 16, 2026). Use your project’s issued specification and amendments for the actual comparison; the guide specification does not automatically govern your project. The checklist below is an original suggested review workflow, not a reproduction of the UFGS requirements.
Eight checks to run against the issued set
Use one record per location or system. The CSV contains the same eight prompts plus fields for source revisions, observed evidence, the review owner, the decision, and closure references.
| Check | Sources to compare | Question to resolve |
|---|---|---|
| What the drawings must show | Drawing note (opening, view window, speaking port, louver, view port, and food pass sizes; door thicknesses, swings, and travels; wall size; glazing type and thickness; frame anchorage method, type, and spacing; a complete door schedule with opening number, type and style, material, design, size, thickness, hardware set, and threshold) + abbreviation note (“Sec. Holl. Mtl.” or “SHM” defined as detention hollow metal) + Door Fabrication note (architectural door schedule) + Door Schedule (Part 3) + door schedule and abbreviation list | Does the door schedule carry every column the note lists for each detention opening, does the abbreviation list define the term the schedule actually uses, so a security abbreviation is not read as a commercial hollow metal door, and are view windows, ports, and food passes sized on the door elevations rather than left to the shop drawings? |
| Door construction, gauges, and thickness | Door Fabrication (custom full flush, internally reinforced, sound deadened and insulated; “gauges indicated for each type of door”; fixed thickness to receive detention locks; HMMA 863 clearances; removable tamperproof glass stop) + Cold-Rolled Carbon Steel (one gauge) + Hot-Rolled and Galvanized Steel (no article says where they are used; galvanized has no coating designation and cites ASTM G60) + drawing note (door thicknesses on the drawings) + door type elevations | If the door types show different face gauges, has the specifier rewritten the cold-rolled paragraph so it does not fix one gauge, does the schedule show the door thickness the section fixes, are any exterior or wet-area doors called out for galvanized steel with a coating designation, and has the specifier said which members use hot-rolled steel? |
| Frames and anchorage to the wall | Door and View Window Frame Fabrication (factory-welded, no knock-down frames; no frame material or gauge stated; head stiffener for wide frames in masonry; mortar guards; floor anchors with a bracket for adjustable anchors “where scheduled”; adjustable jamb anchors for masonry walls; welded frames set into previously prepared masonry openings with a clearance; field-spliced large frames) + Frames (Part 3: security machine screws into expansion shields or a rough buck, a count of anchors per jamb, grout solid, no frames as lintels) + drawing note (anchorage method, type, and spacing) + wall types and jamb details | Which of the three anchorage methods do the jamb details show, is it the one the issued text keeps, does the frame schedule give a frame gauge since the section gives none, are lintels shown over every opening since frames may not carry load, and for frames in concrete or other non-masonry walls, has the specifier added anchorage and grouting requirements, since the section covers masonry only? |
| Hardware reinforcement, lock pockets, and electrified frames | Door Reinforcement for Hardware (factory mortise and reinforce to the approved hardware schedule and templates; hinge reinforcement; reinforced lock pocket with backup plate and protection plate; pull reinforcements) + Frame Reinforcement for Hardware (hinge reinforcement and backup angle; special housing and cover for electrical frame-mounted locks; junction box behind each electrical item; factory conduit within the frame) + Section 08 71 63 hardware sets and templates + electrical and security drawings | Does every detention lock, pull, closer, holder, and position switch on the hardware sets have a reinforcement the fabricator can build, are frame-mounted electric locks and switches shown on the electrical drawings with conduit to the frame, and do the hardware templates required by Section 08 71 63 reach the frame fabricator before frames are made? |
| View windows, glazing stops, ports, and food passes | Door glass stop and View Window Frame glass stop (removable, tamperproof screws of different head types; glass engagement; plaster guards on grouted frames) + closed tubular frames for door lights and food passes + Opening Provision (bracketed speaking ports, louvers, view ports, food passes “as indicated”, no construction requirement) + drawing note (glazing type and thickness) + glazing schedule or security glazing section | Does the glazing schedule give each view window and door light the security glazing type and thickness the note asks for, and is that glazing specified in a section the project manual includes, since this section cites none, and for each port and food pass kept in the bracket, do the details give its construction, frame, and locking, since the section gives only the opening? |
| Sliding doors, thresholds, and finish | Drawing note (“travels of doors”; threshold material) + Door Fabrication (top and bottom edges flush, except weatherproofing) + Factory Finishing (rust-inhibitive primer only) + Adjustment and Cleaning (touch up “prior to painting”, no painting section named) + finish schedule + any sliding door device section | If the plans show sliding cell fronts or sliding doors, which section specifies their doors, tracks, and operators, since this section and Section 08 71 63 cover swinging doors, does the finish schedule assign a paint system to every detention door and frame through Section 09 90 00, and do exterior detention doors have weatherproofing and threshold details? |
| Access panels and their locks | Access Panels (detention steel doors and angle frames, nonremovable-pin detention hinges, stop angles, masonry anchors and a bracket for expansion shields at concrete, baked-on primer; locks at panels within the security perimeter and a bracket for duct and tunnel egress points; keyed alike and entered into the Section 08 71 63 keying system) + Access Panels installation + Section 08 71 63 Type 7 lock (chase and access doors) + Section 08 31 00 + plans and ceiling plans | Are detention access panels located and sized on the plans, are the duct and tunnel egress panels the bracket mentions identified, is each panel lock specified in one section only, since this section and the Type 7 lock in Section 08 71 63 both describe one, and are general access doors outside the security perimeter left to Section 08 31 00? |
| Coordination, submittals, and factory testing | Hardware Coordination Conference (contractor, hollow metal and detention hollow metal suppliers and installers, hardware and detention hardware suppliers and installers, remote control operator and locking device supplier, electrical contractor) + Section 08 71 63 conference (different list, includes the Contracting Officer) + Submittals (shop drawings, product data, and test reports with no “G”) + Source Quality Control (static load and rack test on a door of one gauge, no standard method named) + Delivery, Storage, and Handling (spreader angles; no plastic covers) | Has the specifier merged the two conferences or made their lists match, has a “G” been added to the detention door and frame shop drawings and the test report, does the factory test cover every door type and gauge the schedule uses, and who witnesses it? |
Worked example: brig cell doors with a food pass, mixed walls, and an electric frame lock
Illustrative example: a brig addition has a housing unit with swinging cell doors in grouted masonry walls, a control room door in a cast-in-place concrete wall, view windows in every cell door, and food passes in six cells. The issued Section 08 34 63 keeps all three frame anchorage descriptions and the full Opening Provision bracket. The door schedule lists the doors as “HM” with no hardware set column, the jamb detail shows adjustable masonry anchors for every frame including the concrete wall, the hardware sets give the cell doors a frame-mounted electric lock and position switch that the electrical plans do not show, and the glazing schedule has no entry for the view windows.
Ask the architect to add the SHM abbreviation and a hardware set column to the door schedule, to detail an anchorage for the frame in the concrete wall, to size the view windows and food passes on the door elevations, and to add security glazing to the glazing schedule with a specifying section. Ask the electrical and security designers to show conduit and power to the frame-mounted locks and switches. Ask the specifier to keep one anchorage description per wall type, to state frame material and gauge, to add construction requirements for the food passes, to name the painting section, and to decide which section furnishes the access panel locks.
Avoid a false conflict
Section 08 34 63 covers detention hollow metal doors, frames, view window frames, and detention access panels. Detention locks, hinges, closers, and keying follow Section 08 71 63 and the detention hardware guide, commercial steel doors and frames follow Section 08 11 13 and the steel door guide, commercial hardware follows Section 08 71 00, general access doors follow Section 08 31 00, glazing follows the project’s glazing or security glazing section, finish paint follows Section 09 90 00, masonry and grout follow Section 04 20 00, and electronic security follows Section 28 10 05, so check those before calling a requirement missing. Some of the section’s own wording needs resolving: the abbreviation note defines a security abbreviation as detention hollow metal, the material paragraph fixes a gauge while fabrication asks for gauges by door type, hot-rolled and galvanized steel are listed without saying where they go and galvanized cites a humidity practice instead of a coating, frames have no stated material or gauge, anchorage is described three ways for masonry only, ports and food passes have no construction requirement, sliding doors are implied but not covered, no glazing or painting section is named, access panel locks are also specified in Section 08 71 63, and the two sections call different coordination conferences. Ask the specifier which wording the project intends before treating a difference as a design conflict.
When requirements disagree, follow the project’s document-control and clarification process. Do not assume that drawings always override specifications, or the reverse. Identify the exact sources and request an authorized decision.
Close the issue across the affected documents
Record the location or tag, drawing and specification references, issue dates, observed difference, and the decision needed. Assign an owner and keep the item open until the response identifies the governing requirement. Check the revised drawings and specification references together; a response email alone may leave the issued package inconsistent.
For the overall process, use the guide to drawing and specification conflicts. Mark an inapplicable checklist row with a reason, and distinguish a verified correction from a question that still needs design information.
Where Groundbook fits
Groundbook’s drawing and specification review helps investigate potential disagreements in the documents you supply. Include the relevant specification sections and drawing references, then verify the cited evidence with the responsible reviewers before acting on a finding.