Start with the opening note of the issued Section 08 52 00: confirm that the project is not in a humid climate zone or an ESC C3 to C5 location and does not need blast-resistant windows, because the note says wood windows are not to be used there. Then check that every window type on the schedule has a kept paragraph, that the climate paragraph and U-factor and SHGC brackets match the project’s zone and the energy design, that sound and impact paragraphs are kept only where the drawings call for them, and that the cladding, finish, glass, and sealant sections agree with the window details.
Assemble the review package
Gather the window schedule and window type elevations, the building elevations, the wall sections and the head, jamb, and sill details with flashing and air barrier, the energy compliance documents or envelope criteria with the project’s ASHRAE 169 climate zone and the Environmental Severity Classification from UFC 1-200-01, any acoustic report naming STC or OITC targets, the wind and windborne-debris classification from the structural notes, the antiterrorism criteria for the facility, and the issued Section 08 52 00 with Sections 08 81 00, 07 92 00, 06 10 00, 09 90 00, the flashing and air barrier sections, and 08 51 69.10 if storm windows are used. Follow one window from the schedule to its elevation, head and sill details, glass type, and finish before assuming the others match.
WBDG publishes UFGS 08 52 00: Wood Windows as a public guide-specification reference (accessed November 15, 2026). Use your project’s issued specification and amendments for the actual comparison; the guide specification does not automatically govern your project. The checklist below is an original suggested review workflow, not a reproduction of the UFGS requirements.
Eight checks to run against the issued set
Use one record per location or system. The CSV contains the same eight prompts plus fields for source revisions, observed evidence, the review owner, the decision, and closure references.
| Check | Sources to compare | Question to resolve |
|---|---|---|
| What the drawings must show | Shop Drawing Information (elevations, full-size sections, anchorage, glazing method, operating hardware locations, mullion details, weatherstripping, bar and muntin layouts, screen attachment, connections with other work) + storm window note (show locations; Section 08 51 69.10) + screen note (specify and show screens in medical, food preparation, dining, and sleeping areas) + Windborne-Debris-Impact Performance (“Refer to drawings for classification of window requiring basic or enhanced protection”) + window schedule and elevations | Does the window schedule give each opening a type, size, operation, cladding, finish, glass type, and screen, do the drawings show storm window and screen locations the notes ask for, do the elevations show muntin layouts if the bracket is kept, and do the drawings classify each window for basic or enhanced impact protection where that paragraph is kept? |
| Where wood windows may be used | Opening notes (no wood windows in humid climate zones or ESC C3 to C5 locations; no wood windows where antiterrorism blast upgrades are required) + Anodic Coating note (Class I for humid and ESC C3 to C5 locations) + Organic Coating note (AAMA 2605 for humid and ESC C3 to C5 locations) + UFC 1-200-01 ESC + project climate zone | Is the project in a climate zone and exposure class where the opening note allows wood windows at all, and if the specifier relied on the cladding finish notes, which choose finishes for exactly the humid and corrosive locations the opening note excludes, has the designer confirmed with the contracting officer that wood windows are acceptable there, or switched the openings to a section the criteria allow? |
| Window types, operation, and hardware | Wood Windows (complete units; AAMA/WDMA/CSA 101/I.S.2/A440 performance grade; general hardware plus hardware by type) + Single-Hung and Double-Hung (sash fastener and lifts; note preferring single-hung) + Awning (ventilators in a bay operate separately or in unison; rotary or lever operators; compression weatherstripping) + Casement + Horizontal-Sliding + Stationary + pole-operator note (operating hardware above a stated height) + window type elevations | Has the specifier deleted the window type paragraphs the schedule does not use and kept every type it does, does the awning bracket match how ganged ventilators are drawn, and where the elevations put operating hardware high on the wall, has a pole and pole-operated handle requirement been added, since the note asks for one and the section has no paragraph to edit? |
| Performance grade and air infiltration | Wood Windows (performance grade from AAMA/WDMA/CSA 101/I.S.2/A440; stricter air infiltration per length of sash crack at a stated test pressure; metric value converts the flow but omits the per-length basis) + Window Performance (independent testing laboratory) + structural wind design pressures + window schedule | Do the design wind pressures on the structural notes or the window schedule fall within the performance grade the section names, or has the specifier raised the grade for corner zones and tall walls, and has the metric air infiltration value been rewritten with its per-length basis and checked against the way the manufacturer’s rating states air leakage? |
| Thermal performance and climate zones | Thermal Performance (NFRC 100 U-factor and NFRC 200 SHGC by ASHRAE 169 climate zone; interior windows exempt bracket; fixed visible transmittance; Energy Star bracket for residential units) + Southern, South-Central, North-Central, and Northern Climate paragraphs (zones 1 to 7; metric and inch-pound U-factor brackets that do not convert to each other; no paragraph for zones 0 and 8) + Non-residential Windows (blank SHGC and U-factor with a garbled unit) + note (UFC 1-200-02, UFC 3-101-01, Section 08 81 00) + energy compliance documents | Has the specifier kept the one climate paragraph for the project’s zone, or the non-residential paragraph, and filled its brackets in a single unit system that matches the energy design and the glass in Section 08 81 00, is the project outside zones 0 and 8 or has a paragraph been written for them, is Energy Star kept only for residential units, and does the fixed visible transmittance suit the glass the schedule calls for? |
| Sound attenuation and windborne debris | Sound Attenuation (STC by ASTM E90 and E413 or OITC by ASTM E1332, fixed values and a fixed test glass makeup, no brackets) and note (include only when sound is a design parameter) + Windborne-Debris-Impact Performance (ASTM E1996 basic or enhanced protection, written “basis”, by wind zone; ASTM E1886 test; large- and small-missile brackets by height above grade) and note (UFC 1-200-01 and IBC windborne debris regions; enhanced protection for essential facilities) + acoustic report + glazing schedule | Is the sound paragraph kept only where an acoustic report or criteria call for it, and does its fixed test glass makeup match the glass Section 08 81 00 assigns to those windows, is the impact paragraph kept only in a windborne debris region, with the wind zone chosen, “basis” corrected to basic, and the drawings classifying which windows need basic or enhanced protection? |
| Antiterrorism, glazing, and sealants | Opening note (no wood windows where blast upgrades are required by Appendix B-3 of UFC 4-010-01, titled DoD Minimum Antiterrorism Requirements for Buildings) + Wood Windows bracket (design to Standard 10 of UFC 4-010-01) + References (UFC 4-010-01 titled Antiterrorism, Force Protection and Security Engineering) + glass to Section 08 81 00 + Adhesives (sealants as specified in Section 07 92 00; SD-03 Adhesives with a “G”) + antiterrorism criteria | Which UFC 4-010-01 version does the task order name, do the appendix and standard the note and bracket cite still exist in it, and has the specifier resolved whether wood windows may be designed to the antiterrorism provisions or must be replaced where blast upgrades apply, does the glazing schedule give these windows the glass Section 08 81 00 requires for the antiterrorism criteria, and has the Adhesives paragraph been rewritten so it names adhesives, with sealants left to Section 07 92 00 and the sealant schedule? |
| Cladding, finishes, materials, screens, and installation | Vinyl (PVC) Cladding (preservative treatment to WDMA I.S.4 and Section 06 10 00; ASTM D1784 sheathing) + Aluminum Cladding (WDMA I.S.4 only; AAMA/WDMA/CSA 101/I.S.2/A440) + Anodic Coating (AA DAF45 and AAMA 611) and Organic Coating (AAMA 2603 or AAMA 2605) + Paint (factory primer exempt from the first coat in Section 09 90 00) + transparent finish bracket (one-piece members) + Engineered Wood Products (no added urea-formaldehyde; VOC limit blank) + Fasteners + Insect Screens (ASTM D3656/D3656M; SMA 1004) + Installation (prevent entrance of water and wind) + head, jamb, and sill details | Does the schedule’s cladding and finish match a kept paragraph, does the treatment requirement read the same for vinyl- and aluminum-clad units, if the interior is stained or clear-finished, is there a finish paragraph or a Section 09 90 00 system for it beyond factory primer, is the engineered wood VOC blank filled, and do the head, jamb, and sill details show the flashing, air barrier tie-in, and sealant joints that the installation paragraph leaves to “prevent entrance of water and wind”? |
Worked example: clad wood windows in a coastal climate with an unfilled thermal bracket
Illustrative example: a renovated family housing building at a coastal installation has aluminum-clad double-hung and casement windows, a window schedule with three glass types, and screens in every bedroom. The issued Section 08 52 00 keeps all four climate paragraphs and the non-residential paragraph with their brackets unchosen, keeps the sound attenuation and windborne-debris paragraphs, chooses the Class I anodic finish under the humid-location note, and keeps the Standard 10 antiterrorism bracket. The energy compliance sheet names a humid climate zone, the head detail shows no flashing above the cladding, and the glazing schedule gives the windows a glass makeup different from the test glass in the sound paragraph.
Ask the architect and the contracting officer to confirm whether wood windows are allowed in a humid climate zone, since the opening note says they are not. Ask the specifier to keep one thermal paragraph in one unit system, to keep the sound and impact paragraphs only if the acoustic report and the windborne debris classification require them, to align the sound test glass with Section 08 81 00, to resolve the antiterrorism bracket against the current UFC 4-010-01, and to rewrite the Adhesives paragraph. Ask the architect to add flashing to the head detail and to confirm the screen locations.
Avoid a false conflict
Section 08 52 00 covers complete wood window units. Glass and glazing follow Section 08 81 00 and the glazing guide, aluminum and steel windows follow Sections 08 51 13 and 08 51 23 and their guides, storefront and curtain wall follow their own sections, sealants follow Section 07 92 00, flashing and air barriers follow their own sections and guides, storm windows follow Section 08 51 69.10, and the adopted energy code, UFC 1-200-01, UFC 3-101-01, and UFC 4-010-01 govern performance criteria, so check those before calling a requirement missing. Some of the section’s own wording needs resolving: the opening note excludes humid and corrosive locations that the finish notes then plan for, the antiterrorism note and bracket disagree and cite UFC 4-010-01 under two titles, the metric and inch-pound U-factor brackets do not convert, no paragraph covers climate zones 0 and 8, the air infiltration value loses its basis in metric, the sound paragraph fixes values and a test glass makeup without brackets, the impact paragraph says “basis” for basic, the Adhesives paragraph specifies sealants, and the pole-operator note has no paragraph. WBDG’s history for the November 2018 change also describes the humid-location note as restricting steel windows. Ask the specifier which wording the project intends before treating a difference as a design conflict.
When requirements disagree, follow the project’s document-control and clarification process. Do not assume that drawings always override specifications, or the reverse. Identify the exact sources and request an authorized decision.
Close the issue across the affected documents
Record the location or tag, drawing and specification references, issue dates, observed difference, and the decision needed. Assign an owner and keep the item open until the response identifies the governing requirement. Check the revised drawings and specification references together; a response email alone may leave the issued package inconsistent.
For the overall process, use the guide to drawing and specification conflicts. Mark an inapplicable checklist row with a reason, and distinguish a verified correction from a question that still needs design information.
Where Groundbook fits
Groundbook’s drawing and specification review helps investigate potential disagreements in the documents you supply. Include the relevant specification sections and drawing references, then verify the cited evidence with the responsible reviewers before acting on a finding.