We’re at NCSEA in San Francisco, Oct 28–29 · Booth 110NCSEA · Booth 110 · Oct 28–29

Guide · Specifications and drawings · 23 72 00

Check energy recovery system specifications against the heat recovery flow diagrams, equipment schedules, and air handling units

UFGS Section 23 72 00 Energy Recovery Systems, a USACE-prepared guide specification issued in May 2024 after a complete review that renumbered it from 23 72 00.00 10, is mostly a waste-heat section for power plants and boilers: boiler economizers, boiler or engine exhaust steam generators, engine jacket and lube oil heat recovery, heat recovery silencers, gas turbine heat recovery sections, steam separators, load control condensers, heat exchangers, high temperature water systems, water treatment, and insulation. A shorter article covers air-to-air energy recovery for HVAC: enthalpy or sensible fixed plate exchangers and energy recovery wheels built into heat recovery ventilators, air handling units, and packaged units. Part 3 covers installation, cleaning, posted instructions, training, hydrostatic and plant operating tests, and wheel and plate testing.

Start with the opening and exhaust heat notes of the issued Section 23 72 00: they ask the designer to show on the drawings how every component connects to the boiler or prime mover, with flows, pressures, temperatures, and heat transfer rates, so confirm that a heat recovery flow diagram and equipment schedule exist and that every kept Part 2 paragraph has a tag on them. Then check that the air-to-air paragraphs match the wheels and plates scheduled in the air handling units, that the sensible or enthalpy choice suits each space, and that the tests have scheduled values to measure against.

Assemble the review package

Gather the heat recovery flow diagram and piping schematics, the mechanical equipment schedules for economizers, steam generators, heat exchangers, condensers, and silencers, the engine-generator or boiler plant drawings and the prime mover data, the air handling unit, heat recovery ventilator, and DOAS schedules that carry wheels or plates, the floor plans and sections showing access and clearances, the electrical one-line and motor control center schedule, the structural and seismic support details, and the issued Section 23 72 00 with Sections 23 52 30, 23 52 00, 23 25 00, 26 20 00, 26 32 15 if engines are involved, 09 90 00, the air handling or DOAS section, and the insulation section. Follow one heat source from the boiler or engine through each recovery component to the load it serves before assuming the others match.

WBDG publishes UFGS 23 72 00: Energy Recovery Systems as a public guide-specification reference (accessed November 16, 2026). Use your project’s issued specification and amendments for the actual comparison; the guide specification does not automatically govern your project. The checklist below is an original suggested review workflow, not a reproduction of the UFGS requirements.

Eight checks to run against the issued set

Use one record per location or system. The CSV contains the same eight prompts plus fields for source revisions, observed evidence, the review owner, the decision, and closure references.

Eight specification-to-drawing checksSwipe or scroll sideways to read all columns.
CheckSources to compareQuestion to resolve
What the drawings must showExhaust Heat Energy Recovery note and Engine Jacket note (drawings defining the interrelationship between all components with flows, pressures, temperatures, and heat transfer rate) + Boiler Economizer bracket (performance shown in the equipment schedules) + Heat Exchangers (as shown on drawings) + Installation (detail drawings with piping and wiring, layout, anchorage, and maintenance clearances) + heat recovery flow diagram and schedulesDoes the drawing set include a heat recovery flow diagram that ties each economizer, steam generator, exchanger, separator, and condenser to its heat source and load with design flows, pressures, temperatures, and duty, does every kept Part 2 paragraph have a scheduled tag, and are the paragraphs for equipment the project does not have deleted?
Scope: which equipment belongs hereOpening note (power plant and boiler waste heat; also air-to-air HVAC recovery) + Exhaust Heat note (often better specified with the boiler or prime mover; HRSGs for gas turbines excluded) + Jacket note (often better specified with the prime mover) + Wheel note (wheels built into ventilators, air handling units, and packaged units) + Auxiliary Boiler (Section 23 52 30 Heat Recovery Boilers) + boiler, generator, and air handling sectionsIs each recovery component specified once, here or with its boiler, engine, or air handling unit, is a gas turbine HRSG specified somewhere since this section excludes it, and does the auxiliary fired boiler belong in Section 23 52 30 Heat Recovery Boilers, as the paragraph says, or in the heating boiler section the plant drawings actually use?
Economizers and exhaust steam generatorsExhaust Heat Recovery (integrated package; bracketed exhaust waste heat boiler, jacket and lube oil reclaim, ebullient system, or gas turbine reclaim) + Rectangular Tube, Fin Coil (written as “RTR” twice), and Condensing Economizer Units (ASME Section VIII Division 1 stamp; bypass; inch-pound only) + Exhaust Steam Generator (ASME Section I; modulating bypass that fails to full bypass; flash drum; safety controls) + SD-03 list (no economizer or steam generator item) + boiler breeching detailsDo the breeching details show the economizer or steam generator with its bypass, inspection doors, drains, relief valves, and condensate drain where condensing, has the specifier corrected the fin coil paragraph’s “RTR” references, filled the design pressure and gas temperature brackets in one unit system, and added SD-03 items so the economizer and steam generator are submitted at all?
Engine jacket, silencer, separator, and condensersAntifreeze, Water Jacket Temperature, and Construction (ebullient steam generator bracket citing “ASME Section VII Div 1”, not in References) + Forced Circulation Pump + Lube Oil Cooling + Heat Recovery Silencer (“EGA Rating”; EGSA note not in References) + Steam Separator (steam use bracket) + Load Control Condenser, Air-Cooled (winds, hail screens, motor, starter, location) and Water-Cooled + Pressure-Operated Control Valve (opens on loss of air even if electric) + engine and condenser plansHas the specifier rewritten the jacket steam generator bracket to the ASME pressure vessel section actually listed, chosen the silencer rating and corrected its name to match the site noise criteria, shown the condenser location, distance from the engine, airflow direction, and starter in the motor control center or on the condenser, and made the control valve’s failure position consistent with the operator chosen?
Heat exchangers, water treatment, and insulationHeat Exchangers (shell-and-tube or plate frame; ASME Section VIII Division 1; materials bracket) + Fuel Oil Preheating and Condensate exchangers + High Temperature Water Heat Recovery bracket + Water Treatment (Section 23 25 00) and note + Insulation (lagging surface temperature bracket; heat transfer calculations; outdoor waterproof lagging; Section 01 33 29) + piping schematics and insulation scheduleDoes each exchanger on the schedule match the construction type and materials kept, is the high temperature water paragraph deleted unless the flow diagram uses it, does Section 23 25 00 cover the feedwater and boiler water treatment the note describes, and does the insulation schedule or detail show lagging on recovery equipment with the waterproof lagging the paragraph requires outdoors?
Air-to-air fixed plates: enthalpy or sensibleFixed Plate Heat Exchangers (enthalpy plate unbracketed) + sensible-only bracket and note (natatoriums and kitchens; a different pressure differential than Performance) + Performance (AHRI 1060 seal; sensible, latent, and total effectiveness, EATR, and OACF by ASHRAE 84; UL 723 mark yet “only UL 723” rejected; ASTM E84; ASTM G21; AHRI 1060, ASHRAE 84, and G21 not in References) + air handling and ventilator schedules + space typesFor each scheduled plate, does the space need sensible-only transfer, and if so has the specifier deleted the enthalpy paragraph and rewritten Performance so it does not still ask for latent effectiveness, is one pressure differential stated, do the schedules give the effectiveness, pressure drops, EATR, and OACF the paragraph asks the manufacturer to document, and are the cited standards added to References?
Energy recovery wheelsWheel note (wheels integrated into ventilators, air handling units, and packaged DX units) + Energy Recovery Wheel (AHRI 1060 certified and listed; UL recognized; NFPA 90A by UL 1812 and UL 900) + Cassette Construction (bearing life in years and hours that do not agree; belt rules that skip a band of wheel diameters; double-wall bracket; corrosion bracket) + Energy Transfer Media (sensible or desiccant brackets) + unit schedules and access detailsDoes each wheel on the air handling or ventilator schedule state sensible or enthalpy media, effectiveness, EATR, and OACF, is the corrosion bracket kept where the site exposure calls for it, has the specifier fixed the bearing life wording and the belt rule for wheels between the two size thresholds, and do the unit drawings show access to remove segments for the cleaning the section requires?
Tests, training, and closeoutTests (hydrostatic tests of boilers and piping; boiler inspector; test reports with final control positions) + Heat Recovery Plant Efficiency and Operating Tests (staged load test; performance test procedure with a “G”; fuel and utilities by the Government bracket; water treatment and steam quality tests) + Energy Recovery Wheel and Fixed Plate Inspection and Testing (airflow and pressure drop against “specified values”) + Posted Instructions + Field Training (hours bracket) + O&M Manuals + Field Painting (Section 09 90 00, cited as “Paints and Coatings”)Do the schedules state the airflow and pressure drop each wheel and plate will be tested against, since the section gives none, does the plant test fit the firebox or water tube boilers actually scheduled, is the fuel and utility bracket chosen, are the training hours filled, and does Field Painting cite Section 09 90 00 by its current title, Architectural Paints and Coatings?

Worked example: a generator plant with jacket heat recovery and a sensible wheel for a pool

Illustrative example: a central plant adds jacket water heat recovery to two diesel generators to heat a natatorium, and a heat recovery ventilator with an energy recovery wheel serves the pool hall. The issued Section 23 72 00 keeps every Part 2 paragraph, including the gas turbine section, the exhaust steam generator, and the economizers, though the plant has no turbine and no exhaust boiler. The heat recovery flow diagram shows the jacket exchanger and load control condenser without flows or temperatures, the ventilator schedule lists the wheel as “enthalpy” with no EATR, and the fixed plate article keeps both the enthalpy and sensible-only paragraphs.

Ask the mechanical engineer to delete the turbine, exhaust boiler, and economizer paragraphs, to add design flows, temperatures, and duty to the flow diagram, and to confirm whether the pool hall needs sensible-only recovery, as the fixed plate note suggests for natatoriums, before the wheel media is chosen. Ask the specifier to keep one fixed plate paragraph or delete the article, to add the wheel and plate airflow and pressure drop values to the schedule for the Part 3 tests, and to show where the condenser’s motor starter sits on the electrical drawings.

Avoid a false conflict

Section 23 72 00 covers waste-heat recovery equipment for boilers and prime movers and air-to-air recovery devices. The boilers follow Section 23 52 00 or 23 52 30, the engines follow their generator section and the engine-generator guide, water treatment follows Section 23 25 00 and the water treatment guide, air handling units and DOAS units follow their own sections and guides, and the adopted energy and mechanical codes, NFPA 90A, ASHRAE 62.1 and 90.1, and UFC 3-410-01 govern ventilation and recovery requirements, so check those before calling a requirement missing. Some of the section’s own wording needs resolving: the fin coil paragraph calls itself RTR, the jacket steam generator cites ASME Section VII for construction, the silencer rating is misnamed, guards and platforms point to access door and ladder sections, the submittal list omits economizers and the exhaust steam generator, the enthalpy plate stays in force when sensible-only is chosen, two pressure differentials are stated for plates, the wheel bearing life and belt sizes do not line up, and AHRI 1060, ASHRAE 84, and ASTM G21 are missing from References. Ask the specifier which wording the project intends before treating a difference as a design conflict.

When requirements disagree, follow the project’s document-control and clarification process. Do not assume that drawings always override specifications, or the reverse. Identify the exact sources and request an authorized decision.

Close the issue across the affected documents

Record the location or tag, drawing and specification references, issue dates, observed difference, and the decision needed. Assign an owner and keep the item open until the response identifies the governing requirement. Check the revised drawings and specification references together; a response email alone may leave the issued package inconsistent.

For the overall process, use the guide to drawing and specification conflicts. Mark an inapplicable checklist row with a reason, and distinguish a verified correction from a question that still needs design information.

Where Groundbook fits

Groundbook’s drawing and specification review helps investigate potential disagreements in the documents you supply. Include the relevant specification sections and drawing references, then verify the cited evidence with the responsible reviewers before acting on a finding.

Questions, answered

FAQs

What should an energy recovery system specification review compare?

Compare what the drawings must show, which equipment belongs in this section, economizers and exhaust steam generators, engine jacket, silencer, separator, and condenser equipment, heat exchangers, water treatment, and insulation, air-to-air fixed plates, energy recovery wheels, and the tests, training, and closeout requirements.

Is UFGS 23 72 00 an air-to-air energy recovery ventilator specification?

Only partly. The current UFGS 23 72 00 Energy Recovery Systems on WBDG is mainly a waste-heat recovery section for power plants and boilers, covering economizers, exhaust steam generators, engine jacket heat recovery, condensers, and exchangers, with one article on fixed plate exchangers and energy recovery wheels for HVAC. UFGS numbers are DoD guide specification numbers, not universal MasterFormat titles, and your project’s issued specification governs.

How is this different from the DOAS and air distribution pages?

UFGS 23 74 33 and the HVAC air distribution section cover the air handling equipment itself, including the unit casing, fans, coils, filters, and controls. UFGS 23 72 00 covers the recovery wheel or plate as a component, with its certification, construction, media, and field test, and the waste-heat equipment around boilers and engines. Where a wheel sits inside a DOAS unit, check that the two sections and the unit schedule describe the same device.

Can Groundbook check a heat recovery flow diagram against Section 23 72 00?

Groundbook compares the drawing set with the specification sections and reference documents you upload, such as your issued Section 23 72 00, the boiler, generator, and air handling sections, and licensed standards you hold, and returns potential conflicts with links to the source pages. It has no built-in code library and does not design heat recovery systems, calculate effectiveness, heat balances, or pressures, certify compliance, or approve submittals or tests. Each finding is a question for the mechanical engineer, the specifier, or the contracting officer.

Keep exploring

Continue your review

Check heating boiler specifications against drawings

Compare boiler type, fuel trains, venting, combustion safety controls, hydronic accessories, and water treatment across drawings and UFGS Section 23 52 00.

Explore

Check engine-generator specifications against drawings

Compare the generator parameter schedule, fuel, exhaust, cooling, enclosure, and paralleling across drawings and UFGS Section 26 32 15. CSV included.

Explore

Check dedicated outdoor air system specifications against drawings

Compare DOAS applicability threshold, energy recovery effectiveness, filter rating, and controls protocol across specifications and drawings.

Explore

Check HVAC air distribution specifications against drawings

Compare ductwork, air handling units, terminal units, and fire/smoke dampers across mechanical drawings and specifications. Includes an editable checklist.

Explore

Check unitary HVAC equipment specifications against drawings

Compare packaged and split-system HVAC unit type, efficiency basis, refrigerant safety classification, and controls interface across specifications and drawings.

Explore

Check mechanical water treatment specifications against drawings

Compare condenser, chilled water, hot water, and steam boiler treatment equipment, bleed lines, glycol, and testing with UFGS Section 23 25 00.

Explore

Check hydronic heating piping specifications against drawings

Compare hot water heating pipe material, valve assignment, expansion provisions, and terminal-unit connections across specifications and drawings.

Explore

Check mechanical system insulation specifications against drawings

Compare pipe and duct insulation material, vapor-retarder assignment, and jacket type against the service shown on mechanical drawings.

Explore

Check testing, adjusting, and balancing specifications against drawings

Compare TAB design values, balancing devices, test ports, duct leakage testing, and sound and seasonal tests across HVAC drawings and UFGS Section 23 05 93.

Explore

NFPA 90A HVAC fire and smoke review

Connect NFPA 90A HVAC drawings with rated construction, dampers, access details, and control sequences. Review fire and smoke interfaces across disciplines.

Explore

UFC 3-410-01 HVAC review of DoD mechanical drawings and specifications

UFC 3-410-01, Heating, Ventilating, and Air Conditioning Systems: the versions WBDG lists, how it amends the IMC, and what to check in DoD HVAC sets.

Explore

Drawings vs. specifications

Compare drawing requirements with specifications, schedules, and controls. Find potential equipment, material, and scope inconsistencies with Groundbook AI.

Explore

Bring your next set into focus

Set up a review or talk through your project with our team.

Check your energy recovery spec against the mechanical drawings

Trusted by hundreds of professionals